Monday, April 9, 2018

Universal Soldiers

Erica poses an interesting challenge/question in regards to "universality." Specifically: is there are piece of theater, film, or art that is truly universal? As far as Taylor Mac's play Hir is concerned, I don't think it is. Nor do I think it is trying to be. Hir is specifically about a family in transition. The character of Max is literally in transition, exploring the process of living as a man after being born as a woman; the mother is in the transition of wanting to accept this process so badly that she becomes an uber-ally, advocating for weekend art excursions, a less-than-orderly house, and the slow stripping of power from her husband who certainly had it coming; the son Isaac transitioning back to civilian life after being dishonorably discharged from the armed services. I don't believe this play is trying to be universal, I believe it is trying to paint the picture of the chaos certain facets of society find themselves in as the more marginalized of its members begin fighting for equality.
For me--feel free to picture the dislodging of a tic-tac in my throat here--I think the piece of theater I've seen that is closest to universal is Hedwig and the Angry Inch. 



For those unfamiliar, Hedwig is the story of a self-described "girly boy" from East Berlin who gets a sex change operation so that he/she can marry a U.S. soldier and move to America. The operation gets botched and Hedwig is left with an angry inch of skin, not really man, not really woman, definitely alone and living in the upper midwest of the United States. The lead character of this musical has been played by both men and women, among them John Cameron Mitchell, Ally Sheedy,  Neil Patrick Harris, and Lena Hall. Hedwig's backup singer and roadie is Yitzhak, a woman living as a man because that's how Hedwig likes it (and because, musically, the harmonies tend to work better). Hedwig sings a song towards the beginning of the show where she describes the ancient myth of Plato, who put forth that eons ago human beings were made up of two kinds of sexes joint like siamese twins, back to back. There were guy/guy pairing, guy/girl pairings, and girl/girl pairings. And we were all so happy and complete that we grew in knowledge to the point that the gods got angry, and cut us all in half. We are then doomed to spend our lives roaming the earth searching for our missing half, who when we find them will complete us.


(I posted the original Hedwig, John Cameron Mitchell, and then Lena Hall, cause they are both pretty badass)

 It's a really amazing show, and I think it fits the bill of universality in that the main character works no matter the gender, the secondary character also can be played either way, and in the end every single person who has ever felt a little iota of what is it be in love can relate to the story.

This talk of universality also made me think of the British comedian/politician Eddie Izzard...
Eddie Izzard is a self-proclaimed Action Transvestite. He talks about fancying women and liking to dress like them as well, calling himself a "male lesbian." He's also recently run for political party seats in Britain, and has been very active in demystifying the idea of a man dressed as a woman. On a British talk show he made the comment that he doesn't believe he wears women's clothes, he believes he wears clothes. Period. Why do we need a distinction? It's an interesting question. Maybe the only way to truly achieve universality is to progress to the point where we don't feel the need for boxes of any kind. I'm not gay or straight, male, or female, I am merely...me. Navigating the world as best I can, just like everybody else.
Sadly, this day still seems like a long way off. And part of me believes that the only way to get there may be to NOT aim for universality. Maybe we need to tell stories that are more specific to those that have previously been held voiceless. Tell as many of those stories as possible to the point where they don't seem out of the ordinary anymore. And then begin telling stories incorporating all these new faces and colors and abilities into all of our stories. It sounds like a daydream, but that's generally where progress begins: in the mind of someone, somewhere, dreaming of the day when thoughts of race and religion and gender aren't part of the conversation because the world has moved on and truly doesn't care what you are, as long as you area good and productive person. Right Hedwig?

2 comments:

  1. The transitional quality you identified in "Hir" has a very realistic quality...perhaps this quality possesses the secret of its potential for universality. The analysis provided here is impressive because it probes and provides (at least for me) character arc revelations which tie in to the bigger picture. I find it interesting; the divide drawn between universality and relatable-ness. “Hir” is indeed "...trying to paint the picture of the chaos certain facets of society find themselves in as the more marginalized of its members begin fighting for equality." Perhaps the universal aspect lies in this picture?

    I would venture, that as "Hir" paints this picture, it holds up a mirror to a society grappling with the loss of its opposite feet. As an aside, I think of the binary nature of the world as the right and left feet of a human being. These feet are infested with gangrene, jiggers, ingrown toenails and all manner of imaginable filth, decay and disease, but they are what have held the being up for as long as the being can remember. There are many pairs of bionic feet available for trial and error, but the first step is going to have to be amputation. Ouch.

    As the world takes a turn into the discovery of what true equality can be, it is decapitated from the binary on which it has stood and is left to respond to this change in a variety of ways. Here, we find responses ranging from the over-eager and the know-it-all, to the unrepentant, the stoic, and the unaccepting. Therefore, although "Hir" may not have intended to be a universal play, its world and characters are so reflective of the changing world we find ourselves in that I find myself hard-pressed not to find even an iota of recognition with the world provided. The chaos of the home can easily be a metaphor for a world in transition, caved in on itself and on its old order as it seeks through the mounds for a new one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yep I tend to agree with your sentiments about the need for non-universality. Because how boring and sanguine to write for everyone! And how impossible a task which would just lead to confusing/watered down scripts etc. Imagine thrash metal for everyone- yikes!

    Great examples too- I've been so astounded by Eddie Izzards constant pushing of his own boundaries and through it he has tugged a huge swath of british society along with him into a place where they are undoubtedly more accepting of new norms. Which is what I'm all for- the acceptance of new norms- not in the sense of appropriation but rather in the sense of realizing that widening the tent benefits us all and that the more we can secure with rights, security and access to platform the better off we all are.

    ReplyDelete

Wish I Had a Clever Title But I Don't

My mother is a physical therapist who did early intervention with children. She would be called to make a home visit to assess what, if any,...